
The following originally appeared on Ernesto Aguilar's blog.
The Real Problem with Copwatch
by Ernesto Aguilar
Gathering Forces recently posted a fascinating piece on the nature of Copwatch, a grassroots organizing model for police accountability. As the lead trainer/organizer and co-founder of the now defunct Houston Copwatch (not to be confused with the newer Houston Copwatch), I read the piece with much interest. The defunct Houston Copwatch managed to gain a great deal of media in English and Spanish TV and newspapers, though the work didn’t last. I left the group before it folded, but have to say the Gathering Forces analysis offers some poignant critiques.
First, the good stuff. Copwatch can do valuable community work. The educational “Know Your Rights” outreach Copwatch does, tempered by the understanding that some officers may violate policies regardless, is vital information for youth and others. Addressing the epidemic of police misconduct, as well as the need for accountability for a plethora of community needs is empowering to many people. However, the organizing model offers a lot of opportunities for critique and improvement.
Copwatch as a concept emerged, by many accounts, around 1990 with the launch of Berkeley Copwatch. Since then, Copwatch organizations have popped up around the country. There is really no unifying vision to speak of. Some Copwatch-named groups are positioned around ferreting out bad cops, some around accountability, others on challenging power dynamics. In a historical sense, the challenge to police power was most prominent during the rise of the Black Liberation movement. However, Copwatch, in my estimation, doesn’t have an actual claim to that history, beyond anecdotal reference.
.jpg)




